Book Review: The Peshawar Lancers
Aug. 21st, 2003 12:20 pmI like alternate history. It fits the shape of my mind to go exploring worlds that take off in some strange direction from the one we live in and I love the work that goes into building a believable world. With The Peshawar Lancers I went in knowing a bit of what to expect. Comets hit the world in the 1870s and so now it is 2025 and the British Government lives on in India under King-Emperor John II, of course they are still fighting the reborn Russian Empire in central Asia. It had solid workmanship writing, but in the need I was a bit disappointed. The ending was a bit too perfect, though that could easily be excused by one of the plot devices whereby a character in the book knows what is going on in other alternates. But that in it self brought up a lot of questions that I felt were not answered adequately.
On the other hand I am crazy, liking books heavy on background. I love reading books that are most of the way to being a guidebook to another world. I delight in figuring out how a world ticks. Always there are edges where the world has to be left sketchy and these can either leave me wishing for more or annoyed that it wasn't well enough plotted. Unfortunately the later case is what I felt more often in The Peshawar Lancers. It is not a bad book, but I'm not blown over by it either. I'd call it a fair read.
On the other hand I am crazy, liking books heavy on background. I love reading books that are most of the way to being a guidebook to another world. I delight in figuring out how a world ticks. Always there are edges where the world has to be left sketchy and these can either leave me wishing for more or annoyed that it wasn't well enough plotted. Unfortunately the later case is what I felt more often in The Peshawar Lancers. It is not a bad book, but I'm not blown over by it either. I'd call it a fair read.